In a recent decision[1] on appeal from the WRC, the Labour Court increased a recommended award from €8,000 to €10,000 for an unsuccessful internal university promotion candidate.
The claim was under the Industrial Relations (IR) Acts, which is a more generalised claim. No specific equality issue was raised by the Complainant or presumably the matter would have been brought under the Employment Equality Acts. Claims under the IR Acts are part of a voluntary process and are not normally legally binding unless the parties agree.
Background – Workplace Relations Commission
The original case before the WRC related to a competition at an Irish university to fill 10 professorial posts. The Complainant, a long-serving senior lecturer at the University, was not shortlisted. The Complainant was awarded €8,000 by the WRC, which held that the competition was not sufficiently transparent. The WRC had also made various recommendations such as:
Both parties appealed to the Labour Court.
Labour Court Hearing
The Complainant argued that:
A fresh external review or a higher of compensation was requested.
The University asserted that:
Decision
The Court was concerned by the fact that a declared alleged conflict of interest was not dealt with adequately. While it could not judge whether there actually was a conflict, the fact that it was not dealt with appropriately by the University meant that the process was flawed as a result. It agreed with the University that an external review was not necessary but it increased the compensation award to €10,000 due to the alleged conflict of interest issue.
The case highlights the need for transparency in all recruitment processes and the requirement to deal with any perceived or real conflicts of interest head on.
[1] LCR21904, February 2019
Fieldfisher only collects your personal data for the purposes of your subscription to receive our Legal Updates. To read more please see our privacy policy. We will not use your personal data for any further purpose without your specific consent.
Website by Open